People

Arthur Hutchins

Arthur Hutchins was a stenographer employed in the Indianapolis law office of Senator McDonald during the early 1890s. He is connected to the East Dundee–Carpentersville area through his father, George A. Hutchins, who resided in Carpentersville, Illinois, at least as of December 1891. Arthur's professional role placed him at the center of a notable legal dispute following Senator McDonald's death.

!Scanned newspaper page from Image 3 of The Indianapolis journal (Indianapolis [Ind.]), February 10, 1893, 1893-02-10 (Library of Congress, Chronicling America) Scanned newspaper page from Image 3 of The Indianapolis journal (Indianapolis [Ind.]), February 10, 1893, 1893-02-10 (Library of Congress, Chronicling America) | Source: Library of Congress, Chronicling America

Known Activities

Arthur Hutchins worked as a stenographer in the law office of Senator McDonald, an Indianapolis attorney and politician whose estate became the subject of a contested will case tried at Noblesville, Indiana, in early 1893. The precise nature of Arthur's duties in the office is not recorded in available sources, but his proximity to Senator McDonald's legal affairs made him a figure of interest during the subsequent investigation.

During the trial proceedings, Arthur's father, George A. Hutchins of Carpentersville, Illinois, appeared as a witness. According to reporting in The Indianapolis Journal (February 10, 1893), George A. Hutchins testified regarding a visit made to his Carpentersville home in December 1891, and specifically spoke to the matter of a search conducted through a trunk belonging to Arthur. The circumstances prompting that search — and what, if anything, was discovered — are not fully detailed in the available source material. (Source: indianapolis-journal-1893-02-10)

The McDonald Will Case drew significant regional attention and touched on questions of document integrity and the conduct of those working in close proximity to the late senator.

Timeline

DateEvent
Active c. 1891Employed as stenographer in Senator McDonald's law office, Indianapolis
December 1891A trunk belonging to Arthur was reportedly searched; his father was visited at the family home in Carpentersville, Illinois
February 1893George A. Hutchins testified at the McDonald will case trial in Noblesville, Indiana, providing account of the December 1891 visit and the trunk search (Source: indianapolis-journal-1893-02-10)
---

Notes on Sources and Gaps

Arthur Hutchins does not appear prominently in local East Dundee records identified to date. His connection to the Carpentersville–East Dundee area rests entirely on his father's documented residence in Carpentersville during 1891. It is not known whether Arthur himself was raised there, maintained ties to the area, or relocated independently for his professional work in Indianapolis. Further research in Kane County records, census materials, and Indianapolis city directories from the early 1890s may clarify his biography.

Sources